
Dear Civil Servant,
If your media environment is anything like ours, after the initial coverage of “waves” and “tsunamis,” and the rightful, joyful celebration of the way American voters showed up to reclaim their democracy, you started to hear another word:
Oversight.
Was there ever a wonkier word? But wait — don’t let your eyes glaze over. Oversight by Congress matters, and civil servants are key to its success. But members of Congress have work to do to rebuild trust with would-be whistleblowers from the civil service.
What is congressional oversight, and how can civil servants support it?
Congressional oversight of the federal government has long been understood to be an essential part of Congress’s legislative authority. When done right, it can mean accountability for the government’s or individuals’ abuses of power. It can mean stemming the government’s ability to use its power for harm — whether by cutting off money for retaliatory prosecutions or investigating staffing cuts at CISA. And it can mean unearthing corruption and getting money back for the American people.
Most fundamentally, oversight is one of the key ways that Congress can assert its own authority over federal agencies and civil servants, sending a message to the president that he is not the king, and that the civil service works for the people of this country — not for him personally.
It’s also Congress doing a critical part of its job: The Supreme Court itself has held many times that Congress is not supposed to be “shooting in the dark” when it legislates — it needs information, including about the “administration of existing laws” or “possibly needed statutes,” in order to legislate “wisely or effectively.” That is one of the reasons that whistleblower protections exist, and that they specify that most federal employees have a right to speak with Congress.
The president looks scared; his response to the oversight conversation has been to threaten criminal prosecution of members of Congress. But he is not just scared of Congress — he’s scared of you. The White House counsel just issued a memo requiring civil servants to get authorization from leadership before testifying before Congress, notwithstanding a federal statute that says federal employees’ rights to “furnish information” to Congress “may not be interfered with or denied.”
This is consistent with President Trump’s efforts to hide the government’s operations inside a black box — from proposing that all federal employees must sign an NDA to firing a lawyer who truthfully answered a court’s question to firing whistleblowers, like those who raised concerns about the dismantling of civil rights enforcement at HUD or FEMA’s disaster readiness. Answers are certainly not coming from the top: Trump’s Office of Legal Counsel is now claiming that even many of his communications with “private advisers” are privileged and can’t be revealed, and his own agency heads have stonewalled or simply declined to answer questions posed by lawmakers.
This is why civil servants are absolutely critical to meaningful oversight. You know what has gone on behind the curtain during the first two years of Trump’s second term. If Congress is looking earnestly for fraud, waste, and abuse, you may know where they should start that search. If there is a moment to expose wrongdoing, this may be it.
A breakdown of trust in the safety and efficacy of whistleblowing
However, we understand that speaking out still carries significant risks for members of the civil service. That is one of the reasons we created this guide to speaking out to the media while protecting yourself as a civil servant.
We have also heard increasing reluctance from civil servants to report wrongdoing to Congress. Some whistleblowers have gone public only to not be believed; one was accused by a lawmaker of being part of a “coordinated political strike.” Others fear retaliation if their identities are made public, like an FBI whistleblower who says she was reassigned in retaliation after her whistleblower disclosure to a senator was made public.
According to a survey by the Partnership for Public Service, less than a quarter of civil servants were confident they could report a violation of law without experiencing retribution. And as POGO points out, the systems meant to protect whistleblowers within government have been largely dismantled by the Trump administration. It may understandably feel risky to help Congress do its job by revealing what is happening inside the government.
But even in the face of considerable risk, a number of civil servants have patriotically reported fraud, waste, and abuse — without them, we would not know about ICE’s warrantless home entry policy, DOGE’s mishandling of sensitive SSA data, or DHS’s so-called “Unlawful Voter Initiative.” But civil servants should not have to face those risks, and if Congress wants its oversight efforts to bear fruit, it should start by making whistleblowing safer.
Rebuilding trust: What civil servants need from members of Congress
Members of Congress must recognize that, if they are going to ask civil servants to put their livelihoods and reputations at risk by pulling back the curtain on the Trump administration, they need to show up for those civil servants. Rebuilding trust won’t happen all at once, but here are some places for members of Congress to start:
Make whistleblowing feel easy, safe, and necessary: Members of Congress can conduct outreach to educate their constituencies on whistleblowing rules, why whistleblowing matters, and how their office handles reports.
Consider a contact page or other simple reporting method: Members of Congress could set up secure web pages for communication, or could publicly designate staff members to field whistleblowing reports. Senate Democrats have set up an online portal, though some civil servants prefer to know who is receiving their information.
Investigating retaliation: When civil servants experience retaliation for lawfully reporting fraud, waste, or abuse, Congress should open an inquiry into the legality of the retaliation; other channels for protecting civil servants are largely gone, and Congress can fill the void.
Protecting civil servants’ identities: Members of Congress must ensure that a civil servant explicitly approves their identity becoming public if such a step is necessary—while being candid about the limits of confidentiality. Members should take steps to preserve privacy, including by investigating reports so that the original source may remain private if that is their preference.
Legislating to protect civil servants’ ability to speak up: Congress could invalidate Trump’s plans for a universal NDA, create new means of enforcing federal employees’ rights to be free from whistleblowing-related retaliation, or take any number of steps to stand up for civil servants’ ability to speak to Congress.
Getting practical: How to support oversight
Many civil servants — even those who largely kept their heads down over the past two years — may decide that now is the time to speak up to Congress. Both houses of Congress are putting together concrete oversight agendas. This means the likelihood that civil servants’ information will actually move the needle, particularly if that information relates to key priorities, is much higher than it has recently been.
If you’re a civil servant who’s interested in using your own knowledge and experience of the last two years to help congressional oversight efforts, here is some basic information as you navigate your options:
Consider talking to a lawyer. Retaliation is real, and even if you report anonymously, there is a chance of information being traced back. A lawyer can help you meet your goals while protecting yourself. Government attorneys and members of the intelligence community may face extra barriers to legally protected whistleblowing; members of these groups are strongly encouraged to speak with an attorney. Some organizations that provide free support are listed in the Resources section below.
Wait for the new Congress. It’s an exciting time, but don’t get swept away! The new Congress isn’t seated yet, which means we don’t yet know which members of Congress will lead which committees (more on that below). You also don’t want to be speaking with outgoing committee leadership who won’t have the power to see something through — you want to speak to the folks about to take power.
Where to whistleblow? — i.e., whether to speak to the media or directly to a member of Congress. If you are more comfortable speaking with a reporter, we’ve got a guide for that.
Identify who in Congress needs more information to govern well. Generally speaking, different congressional committees focus on different topics, and you want your information to reach the people who also care about your issue and are prepared to do something with your information. But figuring out committee jurisdiction can be tricky. House committees are listed here, and Senate committees are listed here — but remember the leadership will change in January!
Though the new Congress’s oversight priorities are still taking shape, some of the issues already garnering attention are things that civil servants care deeply about, and that matter for restoring our democracy. For example, employees at NIH, FDA, EPA, CDC, NSF, and other agencies might be interested in plans to investigate cuts to scientific research and the rollback of environmental protections. And employees at the Interior Department (including the National Park Service) and the General Services Administration, which oversee some of President Trump’s favorite construction projects like the White House ballroom, may have insights into the apparent investigation of a top Trump fundraiser for potential corruption surrounding the funding of those projects.
The next two years are a critical period in the American people’s response to autocracy. Voters tasted what it was like to live under authoritarian rule and overwhelmingly rejected it at the ballot box — but now the hard work begins. Current and former civil servants are well positioned to make congressional oversight meaningful. But especially given the threats of criminal prosecution being thrown around by President Trump’s Justice Department, civil servants should take this time before the next Congress to figure out how to protect themselves if they plan on blowing the whistle.
Resources
There are organizations that offer education and legal support to whistleblowers. A few such organizations are:
Government Accountability Project provides education and, in some cases, legal support
Whistleblower Aid provides representation and support
Whistleblowers of America supports whistleblowers who’ve been retaliated against
Project on Government Oversight (POGO) provides resources and education
Justice Connection provides DOJ employees with media support and connects them with attorneys
This publication should not be construed as legal advice on any specific facts or circumstances. The contents are intended for general information and educational purposes only, and should not be relied on as if it were advice about a particular fact situation. The distribution of this publication is not intended to create, and receipt of it does not constitute, an attorney-client relationship with Protect Democracy. This publication also contains hypertext links to information created and maintained by other entities. Protect Democracy does not control or guarantee the accuracy or completeness of this outside information, nor is the inclusion of a link to be intended as an endorsement of those outside sites.




I’m really glad this came to my inbox. Best thing I’ve read since the last thing you sent me. Thank you.